The appraisal clause: how a dispute over the amount of a claim gets settled without a lawsuit

What appraisal decides, and what it does not

Appraisal settles the amount of the loss: what it costs to repair or replace the damaged property, line by line. It does not settle whether the policy applies to the damage, whether an exclusion is in play, or whether the claim was reported in time. Texas's insurance department puts it this way: the appraisal process is for disputes about the amount of a claim, not about whether the policy covers it. If the carrier has denied part of the claim as not covered, appraisal cannot reach that part; the rest can still go to appraisal.

The clause itself

It sits in the policy's conditions section, usually under "Appraisal". The standard wording: if the two sides fail to agree on the amount of loss, either can demand appraisal in writing; each selects a competent and impartial appraiser within a set number of days; the two appraisers select an umpire; the appraisers set the amount of loss, and if they disagree, they submit their differences to the umpire; a decision agreed by any two of the three sets the amount. Each side pays its own appraiser and shares the umpire's fee equally. Read your version; deadlines and the word "binding" vary.

The steps

What to bring

• A line-item estimate in the carrier's format, with photos tied to the lines. Appraisers compare estimates; a lump-sum bid cannot be compared. Ordering one.
• The carrier's estimate, every version, with the dates.
• Every supplement and the carrier's written response, so the appraisers see what was already argued.
• Moisture maps, drying logs, lab reports, engineer letters, whatever supports scope.
• Invoices for work already done, which turn estimated lines into actuals.

When appraisal fits, and when it doesn't

It fits when the scope is well documented and the gap is about quantities, unit prices, or whether items belong in the scope. It fits poorly when the dispute is really about coverage, when the amount in play is small compared with the cost of two appraisers and an umpire, or when the file is thin, because appraisers can only value what is documented. It is also not a complaint: a complaint to the state insurance department is a separate channel about conduct, and the two can run in parallel.

State differences worth knowing

Appraisal is written into the policy, so the clause governs, but states add rules. Texas law now requires an appraisal provision in residential property policies issued or renewed from 2026, with qualifications for appraisers and umpires set by its insurance department. Florida and Louisiana regulate who may act as umpire or appraiser. Colorado's bulletin on appraisal sets impartiality standards. New York's procedure runs through its insurance law. Check the state insurance department's page before demanding; the sources below are a start.

For contractors

Contractors rarely act as appraisers on their own jobs, but their estimate is the document the appraisal runs on. A clean, line-item estimate with photo references and a short scope narrative is what makes an appraiser's job easy and keeps the umpire's share small. A contractor's role during appraisal is to answer scope questions and provide access, not to negotiate.

Order an estimate — first one free

How supplements work